The Florida Key Lime Pie Company - Cocoa Beach, Florida

Kenzie S

Love the variety of key lime and coconut products. This place has more than just key lime. It also has local honey, hot sauce, beef jerky and other treats. But key lime is where it shines. The key lime pretzels were amazing and I liked the slice of key lime pie! I don't know if it's the best but it was good! The little key lime puffs are freeze dried Taffy and they are good but not my favorite (as texture).
The reason for the lower review score would be the olde, larger gentleman (owner I presume) was being rude to his employee. I didn't like the way he spoke to her when she was clearly busy. She was friendly and I have no complaints with her service. Does make you wonder if someone is rude to their employees in public, what they do behind closed doors. However, I cannot judge by one day. Perhaps it was a stressful day. I think the shop itself is a nice place and if you have a chance, try the key lime pretzels they are amazing! They also have other key lime products not mentioned such as ice cream and fudge.

Patricia Foster (Mayalilium)

The lady working there at about 4 was not very friendly. There is only a small selection of ice cream. It's a shame cuz the store is really cute. $3.95 for one small scoop of ice cream. I probably would have been a solid 4 stars if the staff was cheerful or peppy a bit. Seemed a little rude unfortunately.

Natasha C.

This is the best place in Cocoa Beach for souvenirs! They have a variety of delicious food items and cute postcards. A unique find is their collection of political hot sauces and exotic jerky (bison, snapping turtle, python), which may not be for everyone but definitely adds an interesting touch. They also carry a fantastic selection of Florida-made wines, beers, and other locally crafted souvenirs.

If you're visiting from out of town, I highly recommend stopping by. In addition to the souvenirs, they serve ice cream and, of course, key lime pie. For gifts, I picked up white chocolate key lime cookies, Florida orange peppermints, and snapping turtle jerky. Plus, they offer a 10% military discount!

If you get the chance to meet the owner, he’s a fun and friendly person to chat with. My top picks for souvenirs in the area are Florida Key Lime Pie Company, Cocoa Beach Winery, and Ron Jon Surf Shop.

Emma Rost

I am thoroughly impressed with this establishment—it truly captures the essence of Florida in one remarkable shop. The staff are exceptionally helpful and friendly, enhancing the entire experience with their welcoming attitude and attentiveness. On Saturdays and Sundays, they even feature a live alligator for photo opportunities, complete with staff-painting her nails, adding a unique and charming touch. Their selection of house-made ice cream flavors is outstanding, and the key lime pie is nothing short of extraordinary. Additionally, their key lime yogurt-covered pretzels, aptly named ‘Cocoa Beach Crack,’ are an absolute delight and highly recommended. The vast array of saltwater taffy is impressive, as is their extensive collection of hot sauces. They also offer a diverse selection of beers, all sourced from Florida breweries, and an exceptional range of jerky, from beef and alligator to python. This store is truly a gem for anyone seeking an authentic taste of the Florida experience.

neryana padron

A special place that you have to visit... find curious flavors of different products: ice cream, beers, jams and more... KEY LIMEN in different presentations. Great attention and good prices!!!

M. Antonio Monsivais (IREKAIAS)

This has to be the Best Ice cream I've had in the US, and their KEY LIME FLAVOR IS THE BEST, you must come to try this place if you come to Cocoa Beach

ray weithman

What an awesome little shop. Located right across the parking lot from Ron Jon's. Fun atmosphere and friendly staff. Key lime pie and ice cream...what more can you ask for? Beer and Hot sauce you say...They have that too with an amazing selection of hot sauces and local brew. Be sure to stop by on Saturday's and Sunday's to meet Wally, a real live alligator. I love the floor! Ps...not sure of Wally's real name, but worth checking out.

Rachel Arnold

Literally the best piece of key lime pie I've ever had in my life! And I'm a born and raised Floridian. The owner was extremely helpful in assisting our selections. They have a room that's full of all sorts of craft beers. You are able to select a variety and make a 6 pack of regular sized cans or a 4 pack of tall cans. We love to try different beers so being able to select different kinds for our packs was amazing.
Then there was the ice cream. Oh my. Creamy and luscious. And homemade, right there at the shop! You can add a key lime cream sauce on top of your key lime pie ice cream, too! Wow! Highly recommend. Any time I'm over in Cocoa Beach, I'll be stopping in. Thank you!